Free Case Evaluation

Fill out this quick form to get a free case evaluation by our expert attorneys.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

1 800 HURT 511

Learn Why Should You Avoid Personal Injury Settlement Mills

personal injury settlement

Good personal injury attorney works on helping people get the full compensation they are entitled to, while also showing sincere concern for their health and well-being. This might not be the case when working with a settlement mill. In this guide we will cover why you should avoid mills in your personal injury settlement case. Keep on reading to learn more.

Personal injury settlement lawyers are heavily promoted to locals on television and on billboards.

Law firms that handle a lot of cases quickly are known as injury accident settlement mills. They can accept a large number of cases because they typically settle before trial to maximize their profits by resolving the vast majority of their cases through settlement. Companies like this are not associated with defense. They do their job for both themselves and the insurance firms.

What are the signs of a personal injury settlement mill?

There are a number of key differences between settlement mills and traditional lawyers. Rather than actual lawyers, paralegals, case managers, and law clerks typically handle the bulk of the work and responsibilities in a mill. In contrast, when clients continued to work with mass media attorneys, they typically had their initial meeting with an investigator hired by the law firm, after which they signed a contingency fee agreement. A case manager or paralegal took over all further communication and interaction with the client.

This backs up other people’s claims that personal injury settlement mills do their clients a disservice by attempting to mass produce settlements rather than working claims up to their full value.

Ironically, it takes settlement mills longer to resolve claims than it does for merit-based or referral-based businesses. The settlement mills’ staff do not pay much attention to the client’s files for deeper investigation of the case. They try to handle a large number of clients at one time, so they are physically unable to provide quality service to every client.

Why do insurance companies like to work with settlement mills?

Insurance companies love settlement mills because they remove uncertainty and risk from the process. Settlement mills are different from traditional personal injury law firms in many obvious ways: they get more claims, advertise more aggressively, offer a different fee structure, settle claims more quickly and with less work, file fewer lawsuits, and give more work to non-professionals. Even so, the manner in which they resolve claims is unique, indirectly questioning standard theories of claim settlement behavior. Instead of negotiating in the shadow of a trial, as most studies of negotiation assume, personal injury settlement mills negotiate in the shadow of previous settlements. Settlement mill claims are simply and routinely settled at going rates that have been figured out over time by the same people (the settlement mill negotiator and the insurance claims adjuster). These going rates are mostly unaffected by the merit-based assessments and personal factors that would be important if the cases went to court. Like workers’ compensation tables, these going rates are predictable, can be used in most cases, and have less to do with who was at fault than with the severity of the claimant’s injury.

What is the difference between mills and traditional law firms?

Unlike more conventional personal injury organizations, mills take on multiple customers at once. The more cases a law practice accepts, the less time it can devote to each one.

Even if they hired enough people to handle the volume, it is reasonable to expect that the quality of employees would go down as they became less likely to evaluate applicants on the basis of merit. Since they are earning less in each case, these firms must advertise more aggressively as they need as many clients as possible. In a similar manner, businesses are acquiring new customers by attracting uneducated consumers rather than through word-of-mouth or merit. Similarly, they are gaining new clients by attracting uneducated consumers rather than by word of mouth or merit. Both referral-based and mill personal injury attorneys use contingency fees. Meaning, the attorney is only paid if they recover compensation. But personal injury settlement mills only take on claims with no or minimal merit, because they will likely recover something even if the client does not. Though it is arguable whether mills settle faster, there is little doubt that they settle with less effort.
According to research, 90% of settlement mill cases are resolved before going to court.

This may sound like a good thing, since uncertainty was avoided. In fact, if a lawyer does not take more than 10% of cases to trial, it is likely that they are not working hard enough to earn their clients the best potential compensation. Most mill clients speak with an attorney only once. Some people think that only 10% of clients have ever met their lawyer in person.

Insurance companies are well aware of law firms with a mill mentality. They understand that such mill firms are primarily concerned with resolving disputes as quickly and easily as possible. These attorneys have no plans to file a lawsuit.

Choosing a law firm for an injury claim

When, on the other hand, a law firm has a history of settling claims for a few cents, the insurance company will only lower the value of each case. Instead of the lawyer threatening to sue the carrier, the carrier now knows that the mill lawyer never goes to court. So, there’s no reason for them to increase their offer. Also, these law firms will settle the bigger claims with the carriers in a way that is similar to how they settle the smaller claims. This works out well for both the insurance companies and the law firm, but not for the client. Almost all of the law firm’s claims will be settled easily and with little risk, and the insurance company will almost certainly not have to pay out a big personal injury settlement. Since most of these cases are handled by people who aren’t lawyers, the law firm will also be able to make a lot more money.

If you need a personal injury attorney who will work to make sure you get the maximum compensation you deserve, contact us at 1-800-HURT-511. We do not accept more clients than we can handle or settle with insurance companies easily. You will communicate directly with your lawyer after you hire us to represent you. Likewise, get in touch with us if you’re unsatisfied with a lawyer who, in your opinion, fits the bill for a settlement mill. We will help you get started on the path to getting paid for the damage and injuries the accident in New York has caused.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Related Posts

Sanders Aronova Grossman Woycik Viener & Kalant, PLLC Past results do not guarantee future outcome.

© 2021 1-800-HURT-511

Got a Question?

Don’t hesitate to contact us

The Sanders Law Firm

google Trusted Reviews

From Our Clients

Stephanie De La Cruz

I was an UBER passenger and the car got rear-ended by a utility van. I called 1-800-HURT-511 since a friend dealt with them before and I was glad I did. My attorney was extremely professional and aggressive when necessary. He was transparent from the start and didn’t complicate things unnecessarily.

Stephanie De La Cruz
Jordan Barnes

Serious team effort from the entire staff to get my work injury case resolved quickly. They built a strong case and kept me in the loop for the duration. This team also delivered on two previous occasions and did it in a very cost-effective way. A faithful customer for life thank you!

Jordan Barnes
Kevin Diaz

I highly recommend HURT-511! When the insurance companies turned me away after a scary scooter accident that nearly killed me, a lawyer at HURT-511 stayed and fought for me and recovered the entire policy! Their staff is well-informed and always available to answer my questions. They treated me like one of their own and I made the right decision to stick with them. Thank you so much!

Kevin Diaz
Can’t decide what’s best for you?

Call our 24 x 7 helpline to discuss your case now.

Call Us Phone icon
Our locations

    163-07 Depot Road, Suite 101
    Flushing NY 11358

    104-70 Queens Blvd., #501
    Forest Hills NY 11375


    2932 Wilkinson Ave,
    The Bronx NY 10461


    1733 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Suite 43
    Brooklyn NY 11235


    100 Herricks Road,
    Mineola NY 11501

    100 Garden City Plaza, Suite 500
    Garden City NY 11530


    100 Golden Isles Dr, #906
    Hallandale, FL 33009

Free Case Evaluation

Fill out this quick form to get a free case evaluation by our expert attorneys.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.